The high courts had allowed the pleas of several pharmacy institutions against PCI’s July 17 and September 9 resolutions imposing a moratorium on the opening of new pharmacy schools in the country.
A bench made up of Justices BR Gavai and PS Narasimha upheld the Supreme Court rulings and dismissed the PCI appeal that attacked these rulings, saying that the right to impose restrictions on opening new pharmacy colleges cannot be exercised alone by an executive action.
“While there is a fundamental right to establish educational establishments, they may be subject to reasonable restrictions deemed necessary in the general public interest…reasonable restrictions on such a right can be imposed only by statute and not by any execution order,” said Judge Gavai, who wrote the verdict for the bank.
It said the position of the High Courts of Karnataka, Delhi and Chhattisgarh determines the correct position of the law.
The judgment stating that the executive instructions cannot be used to limit the fundamental right to establish educational institutions under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution and ruled that the appeals of PCI can be rejected on this short ground.
“Before we say goodbye, we can state that there could indeed be a need to impose certain restrictions to prevent an explosive growth in pharmacy colleges. Such restrictions could be in the public interest.
“However, if that is to be done, it must be done strictly in accordance with the law. If and when such restrictions are imposed by a competent authority, their validity can always be checked on the touchstone of the law…,” it said.
However, although the bank rejected the PCI’s pleas, the bank said that applications for pharmacy course approval must be accompanied by a “No Objection Certificate” from state governments and approval from member agencies.
“When reviewing such applications, the Council may always consider several factors before deciding whether to grant or deny such applications. The fact that an institution has the right to establish an educational institution does not mean that such an application must be granted.” said.
The Pharmacy Council of India, see its resolution of 17 July 2019, had decided to impose a moratorium on the opening of new pharmacy colleges to conduct diplomas and training in pharmacy for a period of five years from the academic year 2020-2021 .
The subsequent resolution of September 9, 2019, amended the moratorium order and exempted “government agencies; (ii) institutions in the Northeast Region; and (iii) states/union territories where the number of institutions offering D. Pharm and B. Pharm courses (both combined) is less than 50”.
Several private institutions challenged these resolutions before the three high courts and won the case against the PCI, which later moved the highest court.